| hahahahahaha are you actually 🤬🤬 kidding me?! omg | 143 | asthmaticjuuler | | | | |
| Pumpkins new man? | 111 | NecessaryUnlikely438 | | | | |
| Josh’s new girlfriend | 107 | Lost-Coast-6457 | | | | |
| Keelys baby is not Josh’s kid | 81 | Addscom | | | | |
| Really, Pumpkin? | 74 | dietshamrock | | | | |
| pumpkin and josh divorce | 74 | laurens9395 | | | | |
| Bday Cameo | 53 | nifferj | | | | |
| No privacy | 49 | UpsetEmergency5248 | | | | |
| What does Jessica do for a living? | 44 | ExtremeVariation3964 | | | | |
| I got a question about the past two seasons Anna’s cancer journey.. | 35 | Patient-Tailor7308 | | | | |
StoryNote