/r/NotGayIf

Year:

Only show posts with narrations

It’s not gay if you’re soft when she’s pounding you NSFW

61 upvotes • Temporary-Falcon-245

Mark as read: Add to a list

Not gay to dress up and tease your bud with kisses NSFW

60 upvotes • Hotelgoon

Mark as read: Add to a list

It’s not gay, you asked me to prove I was as big as I said…so are you happy now bro? NSFW

56 upvotes • JustTaylorHere200

Mark as read: Add to a list

I'm definitely not gay and my snap is billy241073, I hope you don't add me NSFW

55 upvotes • Honest_Friend_5894

Mark as read: Add to a list

It's not gay if you're just being a good girl for me NSFW

55 upvotes • big_dick_bud_

Mark as read: Add to a list

It's not gay if we shower together to save the environment, bud... 🌎 NSFW

55 upvotes • towergreybuzz89

Mark as read: Add to a list

It’s not gay if you are just helping me with my big blue balls! NSFW

54 upvotes • JustTaylorHere200

Mark as read: Add to a list

Simple logic bud NSFW

54 upvotes • Responsible-Cap-648

Mark as read: Add to a list

It’s not gay, you were just curious to see if I was telling the truth about my big cock…and now you know😏 NSFW

52 upvotes • JustTaylorHere200

Mark as read: Add to a list

I'm Deffo not gay so I hope no guys pm me their snaps because I might accidentally add you NSFW

51 upvotes • Honest_Friend_5894

Mark as read: Add to a list

Title	Upvotes	Author	Mark as read	Favorited	Rating	Add to a list
It’s not gay if you’re soft when she’s pounding you NSFW	61	Temporary-Falcon-245
Not gay to dress up and tease your bud with kisses NSFW	60	Hotelgoon
It’s not gay, you asked me to prove I was as big as I said…so are you happy now bro? NSFW	56	JustTaylorHere200
I'm definitely not gay and my snap is billy241073, I hope you don't add me NSFW	55	Honest_Friend_5894
It's not gay if you're just being a good girl for me NSFW	55	big_dick_bud_
It's not gay if we shower together to save the environment, bud... 🌎 NSFW	55	towergreybuzz89
It’s not gay if you are just helping me with my big blue balls! NSFW	54	JustTaylorHere200
Simple logic bud NSFW	54	Responsible-Cap-648
It’s not gay, you were just curious to see if I was telling the truth about my big cock…and now you know😏 NSFW	52	JustTaylorHere200
I'm Deffo not gay so I hope no guys pm me their snaps because I might accidentally add you NSFW	51	Honest_Friend_5894