| Finally got my swag for getting above a 90 on the ROIP | 12 | _Spirit14 | | | | |
| Garlic epic stuff crust was amazing!!!!!!! | 10 | GenNoFrag94 | | | | |
| Tell me your favorite item (w/toppings) | 9 | ChrispyShmoke420 | | | | |
| Don't Stuff with us John 🍕🍕 | 9 | Mr-Hot-N-Ready | | | | |
| Challenge accepted | 6 | diddler247 | | | | |
| Garlic Parm Breadsticks | 5 | STRYKR_77 | | | | |
| New chicken…. | 5 | Beneficial-Net7113 | | | | |
| Exclusive—Papa John’s Founder John Schnatter: The Troubling Future for Fast Food Franchisees | 4 | coreyb1988 | | | | |
| In response to, 'will staff think I am gay ordering meat-lovers' | 4 | TheoPhilo98 | | | | |
| Rate my conjoined pickles | 4 | MissAnthrope333 | | | | |
StoryNote