| Colin Hated Whistledown (Colin Loves Whistledown) | 84 | Odd_Vegetable9688 | | | | |
| Did people simply not gaf? | 84 | Plenty-Resident9098 | | | | |
| Capital R Rake but now only a rake for Pen | 84 | Defiant-History-5836 | | | | |
| Butterfly Ball look | 84 | Grinandtonictoo | | | | |
| Anyone else? | 83 | Klutzy-Respond2923 | | | | |
| Carriage Scene (Again. . . Sorry) NSFW | 80 | MrsDrMama | | | | |
| Happy 2 year anniversary to the Pirate Colin crumbs! | 80 | lemonsaltwater | | | | |
| Those Small Cruel Voices - A Meander Through Our Intrepid Heroes' Minds | 79 | HonestHermit | | | | |
| I never noticed it, shake it | 79 | aliicia555 | | | | |
| My attempts thus far to land a Colin: | 78 | anewleaf27 | | | | |
StoryNote