| Just my luck | 4 | TheOnlyJuan96 | | | | |
| Guarma | 4 | Automatic-Law-3456 | | | | |
| How does it look | 4 | AdElectrical9895 | | | | |
| Will I get Arthur's horses back? | 4 | Many-Chocolate739 | | | | |
| Fun fact: Gavin’s friend is the only person you can antagonize in Rhodes as a deputy | 4 | JustANormalCoolGuy | | | | |
| Naughty John | 4 | Rauber1 | | | | |
| Ideas for future Red Dead games | 3 | 79N0Bitches | | | | |
| Found some O'driscolls in Valentine even after completing 100% of the story | 3 | Repulsive_Sound2458 | | | | |
| antagonizing micha's friends | 3 | Ill-Atmosphere4609 | | | | |
| Does anyone else get murdered by something every time they get a pelt, or is it just me? I've hunted tons of animals and have yet to successfully make it back to a trapper before a gang of O'Driscolls, or a pack of wolves come from nowhere and kill the fuck outta me. | 3 | One-Faithlessness282 | | | | |
StoryNote