| Immaculate Inning trophy seemed impossible. Didn't even realize I did it until the trophy popped up. (74 pictch ego) | 10 | Carrnage_Asada | | | | |
| Love that Home Run 'DING'! | 10 | GreatIceGrizzly | | | | |
| Contact Swing Power | 8 | ShibeJR | | | | |
| Old School Moose, S1 Finale: Collapse! | 7 | glumpoodle | | | | |
| Hitting help | 6 | knightmare4 | | | | |
| The next 4 contestants on HIT BY THAT LINE DRIVE! | 6 | GreatIceGrizzly | | | | |
| Best individual season you've ever had in a standard franchise? | 6 | badf1art | | | | |
| LET HER COOK!!! | 5 | Papa-Krunk | | | | |
| How do I skip an innings | 4 | nikkstars | | | | |
| Old School Moose, S2 Offseason: Hilarity Ensues | 4 | glumpoodle | | | | |
StoryNote