| Simon Cowell saying Bo Bice outsung Carrie Underwood on their Finale Song, Inside Your Heaven (which ended up becoming their own single for their respective albums) | 4 | cosquilla | | | | |
| Front of the line pass? | 4 | Key_Somewhere_8123 | | | | |
| What's your favorite Katy Perry moment in her 7 seasons in AI? | 3 | cosquilla | | | | |
| Meeting the contestants | 2 | Elinor62300 | | | | |
| Reddit Idol: AI Edition! Vote here for the Group 1 Finale | 2 | MarionCotesworthHaye | | | | |
| Front of the line pass? | 2 | PsychologicalInt | | | | |
| That moment when Katy Perry fell in love in an audition. Man, we gonna miss her. | 1 | cosquilla | | | | |
| That moment when Katy did not want to be respected on the American Idol. She will be missed. | 1 | cosquilla | | | | |
| American Idol Season 1 - Top 8 Show Weird Vibe Shift | 1 | Alarmed_Grab7077 | | | | |
| Who do you think has a more impressive vocal range: Abi Carter or Will Moseley? | 1 | cosquilla | | | | |
