| Bottle Kill Review: Buffalo Trace Single Barrel | 42 | vivahexhotway | | | | |
| Review #250: Subtle Spirits "THE HIVE" (r/bourbon selection) | 41 | whiskytrails | | | | |
| (Part 1) Bourbon Trail Experience Reviews: Lux Row, Heaven Hill, The Bar at Willett | 41 | Dairy_Heir | | | | |
| Review #49: Wild Turkey Rare Breed | 40 | NerdsNBourbs | | | | |
| Barrell Batch 035 Review | 40 | Killsocket1 | | | | |
| Review #4: Michter's Sour Mash Whiskey vs. Shenk's Homestead Sour Mash Whiskey (2023) | 40 | Nervous-List3557 | | | | |
| (Part 2) Bourbon Trail Experience Reviews: Bardstown Bourbon Company and Buffalo Trace | 39 | Dairy_Heir | | | | |
| Review #28: Larceny Barrel Proof C923 | 38 | CuatesDeSinaloa | | | | |
| Review #386: Knob Creek 14 Year 11 Month Single Barrel Select, “Southern Esseneca Edition” Selection (Blind) | 38 | Prettayyprettaygood | | | | |
| Review number 106: Booker’s Bourbon 2018-04 “Kitchen Table” | 37 | taylormhark | | | | |
