| It got out. | 15 | AstralnautLabAsst | | | | |
| any creepypasta with romance in them? | 14 | LampyGames | | | | |
| I Was Renovating my House when I Found a Journal in a Bricked-Up Room. I Hope What's in it Isn't True | 14 | Relative-Tourist7974 | | | | |
| THE CREEPYPASTA FANDOM IS BACK? | 14 | Yourdreamgirl444 | | | | |
| Looking for a creepy pasta. | 14 | JetstreamG | | | | |
| Baldi tortured me NSFW | 12 | Mundane_Election_772 | | | | |
| Does anyone know this creepypasta? | 12 | sunshine020501 | | | | |
| I know this isn't entirely related to creepypastas, but /r/analog_horror is finally back after over a year in the dark | 11 | Tizaki | | | | |
| Looking for a creepy pasta yet again | 11 | Possible_Function491 | | | | |
| I was a 5-React Gum Test Subject | 11 | EricShanRick | | | | |
StoryNote