| Connor deserved getting his ass kicked by Asher | 14 | Thin-Statistician-31 | | | | |
| A Zombie Apocalypse Has Come To HTGAWM 🧟♂️🧟♀️: Who Would Be The Speed Fighter? | 13 | FelicitySmoak_ | | | | |
| The ABC's of HTGAWM Day 10: 'J' | 13 | FelicitySmoak_ | | | | |
| Nate became unbearable in S6 | 13 | sznsbest | | | | |
| Write an r/AmItheAsshole post as the character: Asher Millstone | 13 | FelicitySmoak_ | | | | |
| A Zombie Apocalypse Has Come To HTGAWM🧟♂️🧟♀️: Who Would Be The Second In Command? | 12 | FelicitySmoak_ | | | | |
| Did Laurel drop out? | 11 | mydeardream | | | | |
| Asher is objectively the worst. | 11 | broensoanskkdk | | | | |
| A Zombie Apocalypse Has Come To HTGAWM 🧟♂️🧟♀️: Who Would Be The Weaponry Expert? | 10 | FelicitySmoak_ | | | | |
| All these people belong in jail but here I am still rooting for them. | 9 | Grose040791 | | | | |
StoryNote