| Ed’s Adam and Eve reads | 12 | ghostplay4munE | | | | |
| Reid Faylor (of The Story Must Be Told) live show, Aug. 7th in Madison! | 12 | Rankin_Fithian | | | | |
| New Episode - Side Stories: The Silent Man | 11 | PM-ME-YOUR-POEM | | | | |
| what are your favorite henry creepypasta ep stoned call to actions | 8 | hideousbeautifulface | | | | |
| Hometown shoutout! | 7 | gergsisdrawkcabeman | | | | |
| Lily E Gray. Victim of the beast. Salt Lake City Cemetery, SLC, UT. Finally got a chance to see it in person | 7 | ghoulslaw | | | | |
| Noticed these fish sounded familiar 🤔 | 6 | Bassisisto | | | | |
| This guy has the power of the Ham | 6 | Herudo2 | | | | |
| Ragnar Interview | 5 | HeartOfPine | | | | |
| Mysterious bags of liquid littering small town | 4 | Jerome-Fappington | | | | |
