/r/notgayatall

Year:

Only show posts with narrations

It's not if I smash you after we play baseball right? You were just cheering me on. NSFW

22 upvotes • TomatilloObvious04

Mark as read: Add to a list

Not gay if my buddy needs advice... said he met this hot girl on a dating app... and he plans on fucking her and just needed an opinion. maybe he can cancel his date and I'll show him he doesn't need her NSFW

22 upvotes • MoFoTY86

Mark as read: Add to a list

It’s not gay if we don’t get caught bu-oh fuck pull your pants up! I can’t get my cock away…did they see us!?😳 NSFW

22 upvotes • JustTaylorHere200

Mark as read: Add to a list

We are just watching porn together. Nothing gay about that. NSFW

22 upvotes • bitogo

Mark as read: Add to a list

It’s not gay as long as your wife is with us right? (Me and who’s wife be like hehe?) NSFW

21 upvotes • Initial_Birthday7057

Mark as read: Add to a list

Not gay if were gooning you just like my bwc NSFW

21 upvotes • Key-Ad-5342

Mark as read: Add to a list

when a straight white man runs into a straight asian guy in the shower at the gym NSFW

21 upvotes • Level-Extension5467

Mark as read: Add to a list

Not gay if we struck out at he club and you drew the short straw NSFW

21 upvotes • Key-Ad-5342

Mark as read: Add to a list

it's not gay if they're teaching you a lesson NSFW

21 upvotes • Opening_Preference78

Mark as read: Add to a list

It’s not gay if you’re relieving my backed-up nuts with a throatpussy jizz extraction NSFW

21 upvotes • Throatwreck2

Mark as read: Add to a list

Title	Upvotes	Author	Mark as read	Favorited	Rating	Add to a list
It's not if I smash you after we play baseball right? You were just cheering me on. NSFW	22	TomatilloObvious04
Not gay if my buddy needs advice... said he met this hot girl on a dating app... and he plans on fucking her and just needed an opinion. maybe he can cancel his date and I'll show him he doesn't need her NSFW	22	MoFoTY86
It’s not gay if we don’t get caught bu-oh fuck pull your pants up! I can’t get my cock away…did they see us!?😳 NSFW	22	JustTaylorHere200
We are just watching porn together. Nothing gay about that. NSFW	22	bitogo
It’s not gay as long as your wife is with us right? (Me and who’s wife be like hehe?) NSFW	21	Initial_Birthday7057
Not gay if were gooning you just like my bwc NSFW	21	Key-Ad-5342
when a straight white man runs into a straight asian guy in the shower at the gym NSFW	21	Level-Extension5467
Not gay if we struck out at he club and you drew the short straw NSFW	21	Key-Ad-5342
it's not gay if they're teaching you a lesson NSFW	21	Opening_Preference78
It’s not gay if you’re relieving my backed-up nuts with a throatpussy jizz extraction NSFW	21	Throatwreck2