| Can we please get a solved case | 188 | One_Rip_5535 | | | | |
| UK crime junkies please help! (I do not know this woman personally, my brother in law works with her, but I want to help in any way I can) | 51 | weinerburgers | | | | |
| Robin Pope (enraged) | 45 | HunterandGatherer100 | | | | |
| Underwhelmed by premium access | 41 | Chicken_Small | | | | |
| are there other podcasts like crime junkie? | 38 | Swimming-Judge1865 | | | | |
| Positive Feedback | 31 | 9149790 | | | | |
| Forgettable Episodes :( | 21 | bluetopaz__ | | | | |
| Town helps abuse victim with the murder of her husband | 20 | No_Average_7812 | | | | |
| What are some words or quotes that only CJ listeners will understand? | 12 | LimpingIceberg | | | | |
| What case has stuck to you for so long that you’ve done deep research dives on it, and what else did you find?! | 9 | Tea_Resident | | | | |
