| Found in a public bathroom | 3495 | velvetelevator | | | | |
| Found paper in Arches National Park in 2017 :( | 1380 | Mammoth_Math4629 | | | | |
| Found in a thrift shop | 907 | mojopin97123 | | | | |
| Found in a secret compartment in my grandad’s wallet | 672 | Designer_Violinist74 | | | | |
| Found in an used copy I bought of my favorite book. | 536 | edmarry | | | | |
| Found in a book at a thrift store | 363 | Imaginary-Choice-560 | | | | |
| Found in Jacksonville FL April of 2022 (names removed for privacy) | 345 | serbiatch735 | | | | |
| Found in a bush I was hedging, pretty sure this is a 12 year old boy based on the reference to year 7 | 267 | pokerchip99 | | | | |
| I found a letter in an old Paul McCartney book, what do I do? | 224 | georgeharrisonswife | | | | |
| Found in a copy of HP Lovecraft’s At The Mountains of Madness | 196 | LauraHday | | | | |
