| Is this a new one??? | 324 | KickOriginal7239 | | | | |
| Ummm…Does someone want to explain this? | 271 | Available_Mongoose48 | | | | |
| Logged in for the 1st time since Season 1 | 234 | logank33 | | | | |
| I guess pitchers can’t make the Hall of Fame in Franchise Mode, because this dude didn’t? | 225 | 92tilinfinityand | | | | |
| Every TA Update Day 1 | 210 | TrapperJean | | | | |
| I will never achieve this ever again | 178 | L3beat | | | | |
| Walk-off hit implanted into Roy Oswalt's skull | 169 | Brazenology | | | | |
| Reds custom card ideas / New legend ideas | 169 | InternationalSink787 | | | | |
| One of the wildest ranked finishes you’re ever likely to see | 158 | scarey102 | | | | |
| I just got spanked by Michael Harris II….. | 150 | Drugwarveteran92 | | | | |
StoryNote