| 5/9ths of my starting line up is named Juan | 158 | Historical-Ruin-1933 | | | | |
| Probably the most Italian prospect I’ve come across | 147 | HungryVillagers | | | | |
| Never seen a preseason prediction this atrocious | 73 | trevortime22 | | | | |
| Why can't this guy get in the HoF? He's in his 5th year of eligibility and hasn't gotten close. | 69 | relder17 | | | | |
| Pet peeve: in seasons where players played for more than one team, the teams are often out of chronological order. I don't recall this happening in earlier versions (I'm on OOTP 25). | 66 | hubagruben | | | | |
| After signing a massive contract, this pitcher opted out and got $61M in arbitration | 54 | eggsnorter222 | | | | |
| Seems like an Unfair Nickname... | 39 | LoveYouLikeYeLovesYe | | | | |
| Even Year K-Rod gets much more love than Odd Year K-Rod | 38 | JamboPls | | | | |
| Age 31: 300 HR,300 2B, 76.1 WAR, 7 MVP awards, 4 GG & 8 SS. The best player I have ever seen in a save of mine | 38 | KimiBwoah | | | | |
| New to OOTP - Really Overwhelmed | 37 | telekaster57 | | | | |
