| Sheriff Mike aka Big Black (unapologetically himself) | 131 | thel0stminded | | | | |
| This show helped me with my anxiety | 122 | theroyalblacksmith | | | | |
| Made a poster for my wall and thought I’d share with y’all! | 92 | drugfueledsarcasm | | | | |
| Can we take time out of our day to appreciate burglar goth Harry | 72 | SinningSynapses | | | | |
| Late-night artwork | 68 | ddub74012 | | | | |
| The part that makes me so sad and made me cry several times (spoiler) | 61 | Low_Departure_5853 | | | | |
| Ben & Kate beating up MiBs | 53 | Good_Ad3485 | | | | |
| I have a theory about the real Harry Vanderspeigle | 51 | Nimrochan | | | | |
| Colorado | 46 | AerynXIV | | | | |
| What is the secret recipe for how this show is so good? | 44 | newaccount1000000 | | | | |
StoryNote