| 8 years, oh how the time flies. | 106 | Shadowkiller00 | | | | |
| Its my cake day pls get me to positive comment karma | 87 | Real_Rebelchunk | | | | |
| 5 years on reddit… | 66 | HailMuss | | | | |
| I am now eleven Reddit years old! Love me! | 64 | kindestcut | | | | |
| 4 years Cake Day, Time flies🍰 | 63 | yungdaggertekashi | | | | |
| My reddit account is now old enough for a US driver's license. | 61 | adlittle | | | | |
| Hell yeah it’s my 10yr Reddit anniversary!!! | 44 | Calistyle510 | | | | |
| 12 year cake day. | 41 | StaleMonkey | | | | |
| My first Cakeday! | 41 | ValuableAttention101 | | | | |
| Happy 5th Cake Day to Me! | 41 | LikeaLamb | | | | |
StoryNote