| Why do I feel like this belongs here? | 52 | Donloco00 | | | | |
| What’s Haunting YOU? Recording Submissions | 33 | NatStrawn | | | | |
| New Cryptos | 33 | veniceb1tch15 | | | | |
| Ok, who put the butthole sticker on the Mothman statue? | 28 | ligokleftis | | | | |
| Haunties, what's the scariest thing to ever happen to you at 3am? | 25 | thealterry | | | | |
| Podcast Awards Reminder | 11 | AponeMC | | | | |
| Selkie Wine 😋 | 11 | Dangerous-Student-15 | | | | |
| Since we all know how much Nat loves treasure… | 11 | Donloco00 | | | | |
| Street Light Interference | 11 | Wally1979 | | | | |
| Zodiac Killer ?? | 10 | palefrogs | | | | |
StoryNote