| aye we be in for a tough time mateys | 743 | Just-A-Lizzerd | | | | |
| Shiver me timbers | 567 | yeetus-maxus | | | | |
| No sailswifes for ye | 414 | KEEP_IT_REAL3 | | | | |
| blackbeard's hierarchy o' needs | 400 | Tongonto | | | | |
| Well shit | 321 | HostileBread | | | | |
| ARRRRRRRRRGH… | 300 | ItsNeeeeeeeeeeeeeko | | | | |
| YAHARR, YE’VE BEEN PLUNDERED | 296 | The-Suzookie-Dookie | | | | |
| His name? Wang Chih | 264 | XqNcFpXeLd | | | | |
| Yahar | 237 | friedshoe22 | | | | |
| Hit that sack o' bones wit the captain's stare | 222 | the_council_of_apes | | | | |
StoryNote