| Wayne's World 2 (1993). Only 60% on RottenTomatoes, and didn't have near the box office success as the original, but I really enjoyed it. | 1113 | smcg_az | | | | |
| Dogma (1999) | 912 | snubblecheak | | | | |
| Truly underrated | 908 | Distinct_Sentence_26 | | | | |
| What about Bob? (1991) | 645 | Trixie1143 | | | | |
| PCU (1994) | 603 | bazar79 | | | | |
| Mystery Men (1999) | 579 | Slaiyve | | | | |
| Take Shelter (2011) Despite high critical praise, this Michael Shannon feature grossed only $3.7 million at the box office and is still largely unknown. | 502 | MachineHeart | | | | |
| What's your favorite Thanksgiving Movie? (1991) | 492 | Tonio775 | | | | |
| Scrooged (1988) | 424 | cometpapaya | | | | |
| Encino Man 1992 | 417 | Burn_em_again | | | | |
StoryNote